Downsides of Consumer Proposals: What You Should Know

Introduction

In the quest for financial stability, many individuals facing debt challenges consider a consumer proposal as a viable solution. This process allows debtors to come to an arrangement with their creditors to pay a portion of what they owe over a set period, which can undoubtedly seem like a financial lifeline. However, like any significant financial decision, it’s crucial to understand all aspects, including the downsides. Here, we delve into the less talked about aspects of consumer proposals, helping you make an informed decision.

Impact on Credit Rating

One of the immediate consequences of filing a consumer proposal is its impact on your credit score. It is recorded on your credit report and can significantly lower your credit rating. A consumer proposal stays on your credit report for at least three years after you have completed all payments, making it challenging to obtain new credit, mortgages, or loans during this period. This can be a significant drawback for individuals looking to rebuild their financial standing quickly.

Not All Debts Can Be Included

It’s a common misconception that all debts can be resolved through a consumer proposal. Certain obligations, such as secured loans (e.g., mortgages, car loans), child support and alimony payments, student loans (if it has been less than seven years since you were a student), and court-imposed fines or penalties, cannot be included in your proposal. This limitation can necessitate finding alternative solutions for these debts, complicating your financial recovery plan.

Limited Control and Flexibility

By entering into a consumer proposal, you agree to a structured payment plan over a specific period, typically not exceeding five years. This commitment means you have limited flexibility in managing these payments. Should your financial situation improve significantly, your creditors might request an increase in payments or an earlier completion of the proposal. Conversely, if your financial situation worsens, you may find yourself unable to renegotiate the terms, which could lead to the annulment of the proposal and facing bankruptcy.

Costs Involved

While a consumer proposal can reduce the overall debt owed, it is not without costs. Filing a proposal involves fees for the Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT), who administers your proposal and acts as a mediator between you and your creditors. These fees are regulated by the government but are taken from the payments you make under the proposal. It’s important to consider these costs when calculating the total amount you will be paying toward your debts.

Public Record and Social Stigma

A less considered but equally significant downside is that your consumer proposal becomes a matter of public record. This exposure can have personal and professional ramifications, particularly if your occupation requires financial reliability. Additionally, there can be a social stigma associated with filing a consumer proposal or bankruptcy, which can affect personal relationships and mental health.

Conclusion

A consumer proposal can offer a path out of overwhelming debt, but it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. The impact on your credit rating, the limitations on which debts can be included, the lack of flexibility, the costs involved, and the potential for public exposure and social stigma are all critical factors to consider. Before making a decision, it’s advisable to consult with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee to explore all your options and to thoroughly understand the implications of a consumer proposal on your financial future.

See if you qualify for debt relief